Posted on: May 7, 2010 2:49 pm
The Miami Dolphins have famously done little about their quarterback position since the retirement of Dan Marino. They've essentially left journeymen in the job instead of going after a top talent, and have done so year after year. On the one occurrence where they did try to fix the position, they managed one of the biggest blunders in recent free agent memory, taking an essentially done for quarterback and letting Drew Brees go to New Orleans to have career seasons ever since.
When I had this discussion with my brother, he opined that the Dolphins don't need to do anything, because they have the (highly touted?) Chad Henne on the roster. For his sake as a fan, I hope that he is right.
In Charlotte, the Panthers were faced with a similar problem. The fortunes of Jake Delhomme have been fading consistently since the Super Bowl year, to the point where the Panthers finally released him after the 2009 season. In hand is a young man named Matt Moore.
Moore and Henne have similarities. Both are young quarterbacks with limited experience who took over from injured starters last year. Henne played 14 games, had about a 60% completion rate, and threw 14 interceptions to 12 touchdowns. Moore played seven games, had about a 62% completion rate, and had an impressive ratio of 8 TDs to 2 interceptions.
From those stats, if either team was going to shore up their depth at the position thru the draft, you would think it would be the Dolphins. Yet it was the Panthers who rolled the dice on coming up with a big talent at the most important position on a football team, and came up with Jimmy Clausen. Give the Panthers credit. They were willing to do what most of a round and a half of teams before them weren't willing to do ... take a shot at greatness.
I could be wrong and I hope I am, but I fear that the Dolphins have once again willingly chosen mediocrity over a shot to be really good. Back when they drafted Dan Marino, they took a chance on a talented college QB that had a bad reputation for too high a ratio of interceptions to TDs. They thought he might work that out with experience. They were right, and came out with one of the great quarterbacks in the history of the NFL. Its sad that the current management in Miami has no such vision. The Panthers haven't really been known as a visionary team either, although they have consistently made solid moves and seem to contend at least every other year. This draft tho, the rest of the teams placed a shot at greatness right in their laps, and they didn't fumble that chance away. Now Clausen might or might not work out as a great quarterback, but if you don't reach out for it, you'll never grab the ring. The Panthers have reached, and I applaud them.
Posted on: January 22, 2008 5:43 pm
Edited on: January 22, 2008 8:14 pm
I'm going to use my first blog post to cover a topic I've found myself writing on two years in a row, after the career moves by Nick Saban and Bobby Petrino.
I'm also going to use it as an opportunity to preserve a post I made some weeks ago on the subject.
Bear in mind that I barely knew who Petrino was before he moved to the Falcons, and hadn't paid much attention to Saban before he took the Dolphins job. As a disclaimer, I was born in Alabama and have been a lifelong fan of the Crimson Tide. I went to High School in Florida, starting the same year the Dolphins went 17-0, and was a fan up until the eventual retirements of Shula and Dan Marino. I was also a long time Falcons fan, having lived in Atlanta during the years my interest in pro football was developing, and gone back to the city during my time in college (or should I say "Institute").
In many cases I tend to be a fan of individual coaches or players rather than a team as an entity, and so have been known to abandon fandom for some teams when it has gotten ot the point that all of the people that drew me to a team are long gone.
My one time fandom for the Dolphins, and lifelong fandom of Alabama, however, do not influence my ideas on the merits of this discussion. I've long held these beliefs, predating this specific situations by decades.
I always have to shake my head in wonderment that sports fans think they have any right to stand in judgement of a career decision made by a coach or player.
Of course Saban's situation from last year has been drawn into this discussion of Petrino, and both men had an absolute right to make a decision based on what they felt was best for them and their families.
Now, I was a Falcon's fan on the day they started playing, and a Dolphin's fan for more than 40 years. Alhough I've been a fan of those teams, I never wore the rose colored glasses. The Falcons have never been a well manaaged franchise, and the Dolphins have done nothing but go downhill since Wayne bought them. (I'm sure the dynamics in Miami are more complicated than just Wayne's ownership, but that is another discussion).
However, in both cases these coaches found the reality of their situation with the team to be different than the expectations 'sold' to them when they took the positions, and likely discovered after fighting through the cold veil of experience that they were happiest in a different situation.
Life is both too long and too short to spend it in a situation where you are not happy or comfortable, if you have a choice.
It is very unusual for either a college or pro coach to stay in one position indefinitely any more, and it is more often the franchise or university that makes the choice, rather than the coach. To blame a coach for being the one to make the decision rather than the franchise really doesn't make any sense. Both Saban and Petrino would have eventually been fired by their pro franchise, after some number of years, no matter what success they achieved, unless they won the Super Bowl every year.
You cannot blame them for making a move on their own terms when an opportunity came along that they like better. Both took pay cuts, both knew they'd face criticism for leaving. That alone tells you a lot about how important it was to those two men to get out of the traps they found themselves in.
Head coach of the Falcons has NEVER been a long term career, and likely never will be.
The Dolphins have done a better job of sticking by coaches since Shula left, but their stubborn refusal to make a fundamental decision to fix the quarterback position is going to hamstring that team until they wise up and do so. Did Saban fix the QB situation? No. But that problem predated him by years, so its hard to blame him for it.
Here's the bottom line. These men have the right to make their own decisons regarding their professional futures, just like we do. Venomous criticisms of their career decisions are useless, ineffective, and really, completely out of line.
If you feel inclined to ridicule these men, the next time you make a career decision for the sake of your happiness and that of your family, ask yourself if you think its anyone's business to criticize it in media, message boards, or at all.
As a side discussion, you'd think it would be detrimental to a coach's career to do very much 'job jumping', yet history does not seem to bear this out. Nick's cousin, Lou Saban, jumped coaching jobs constantly throughout his career, and never seemed to have a problem finding his next coaching job. Interestingly, he once acknowledged this, but said that he always thought the next job was going to be the one that lasted until he decided to retire. I really believe he meant that, yet the temptation was always somehow too strong to enter the next green pasture.